2009 Steve Mason - Columbus Blue Jackets
2008 Patrick Kane - Chicago Blackhawks
2007 Evgeni Malkin - Pittsburgh Penguins
2006 Alexander Ovechkin - Washington Capitals
2005 No Calder Memorial Trophy Awarded due to strike season
2004 Andrew Raycroft - Boston Bruins
2003 Barret Jackman - St. Louis Blues
2002 Dany Heatley - Atlanta Thrashers
2001 Evgeni Nabokov - San Jose Sharks
2000 Scott Gomez - New Jersey Devils
1999 Chris Drury - Colorado Avalanche
1998 Sergei Samsonov - Boston Bruins
1997 Bryan Berard - New York Islanders
1996 Daniel Alfredsson - Ottawa Senators
1995 Peter Forsberg - Quebec Nordiques
1994 Martin Brodeur - New Jersey Devils
1993 Teemu Selanne - Winnipeg Jets
1992 Pavel Bure - Vancouver Canucks
1991 Ed Belfour - Chicago Blackhawks
1990 Sergei Makarov - Calgary Flames
1989 Brian Leetch - New York Rangers
1988 Joe Nieuwendyk - Calgary Flames
1987 Luc Robitaille - Los Angeles Kings
1986 Gary Suter - Calgary Flames
1985 Mario Lemieux - Pittsburgh Penguins
1984 Tom Barrasso - Buffalo Sabres
1983 Steve Larmer - Chicago Blackhawks
1982 Dale Hawerchuk - Winnipeg Jets
1981 Peter Stastny - Quebec Nordiques
1980 Ray Bourque - Boston Bruins
1979 Bobby Smith - Minnesota North Stars
1978 Mike Bossy - New York Islanders
1977 Willi Plett - Atlanta Flames
1976 Bryan Trottier - New York Islanders
1975 Eric Vail - Atlanta Flames
1974 Denis Potvin - New York Islanders
1973 Steve Vickers - New York Rangers
1972 Ken Dryden - Montreal Canadiens
1971 Gilbert Perreault - Buffalo Sabres
1970 Tony Esposito - Chicago Blackhawks
1969 Danny Grant - Minnesota North Stars
1968 Derek Sanderson - Boston Bruins
1967 Bobby Orr - Boston Bruins
1966 Brit Selby - Toronto Maple Leafs
1965 Roger Crozier - Detroit Red Wings
1964 Jacques Laperriere - Montreal Canadiens
1963 Kent Douglas - Toronto Maple Leafs
1962 Bobby Rousseau - Montreal Canadiens
1961 Dave Keon - Toronto Maple Leafs
1960 Bill Hay - Chicago Blackhawks
1959 Ralph Backstrom - Montreal Canadiens
1958 Frank Mahovlich - Toronto Maple Leafs
1957 Larry Regan - Boston Bruins
1956 Glenn Hall - Detroit Red Wings
1955 Ed Litzenberger - Chicago Blackhawks
1954 Camille Henry - New York Rangers
1953 Lorne Worsley - New York Rangers
1952 Bernie Geoffrion - Montreal Canadiens
1951 Terry Sawchuk - Detroit Red Wings
1950 Jack Gelineau - Boston Bruins
1949 Pentti Lund - New York Rangers
1948 Jim McFadden - Detroit Red Wings
1947 Howie Meeker - Toronto Maple Leafs
1946 Edgar laprade - New York Rangers
1945 Frank McCool - Toronto Maple Leafs
1944 Gus Bodnar - Toronto Maple Leafs
1943 Gaye Stewart - Toronto Maple Leafs
1942 Grant Warwick - New York Rangers
1941 Johnny Quilty - Montreal Canadiens
1940 Kilby MacDonald - New York Rangers
1939 Frank Brimsek - Boston Bruins
1938 Cully Dahlstrom - Chicago Blackhawks
1937 Syl Apps - Toronto Maple Leafs
1936 Mike Karakas - Chicago Blackhawks
1935 Dave Schriner - New York Americans
1934 Russ Blinko - Montreal Maroons
1933 Carl Voss - Detroit Red Wings